By clicking “Accept All Cookies”, you agree to the storing of cookies on your device to enhance site navigation, analyse site usage, and assist in our marketing efforts. View our Privacy and Cookies Policy for more information.
red cross sign

get in touch

Interested in reviewing one of our books?
Use this form to request a Review Copy.
Submissions will next be welcomed in February 2022.
More information on our submissions process is available here.
work with us
We welcome enquiries regarding business collaborations. For information on Permanent Vacancies and Internships/Placements, visit out About page.
Thanks, you're all signed up.
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
white icon of a shopping bag
0
Book bag
Bashabi Fraser and Vibha Pankaj with Patient dignity between

Review of Patient Dignity in London Diary column of Anandabajar

Read the English translation of Shrabani Basu’s review of ‘Patient Dignity’ which has been published in Anandabajar in their ‘London Diary’ column- a Bengali newspaper with the highest sales both in India and amongst the Bengali diaspora internationally.

'London Diary' A review of Patient Dignity by Bashabi Fraser with artwork by Vibha Pankaj

She is known as the poet and author who has always brought together her roots in Bengal with her life in Scotland. Bashabi Fraser, professor emeritus of English and creative writing at Edinburgh Napier University, has now published a book of poetry inspired by the lockdown and the coronavirus pandemic. Like others around the world, to Fraser, the lockdown meant separation from family, zoom calls and anxiety. But it was also a time, when as things stopped, the skies got clear, and people heard the celebratory music of birds in a new dawn. “Ceasefires were called by the UN,” she writes, “and there was hope that the need for wars and weaponry might be considered a contradiction when human survival became a prerogative.”

The book of poems called “Patient Dignity” covers the different aspects of the pandemic – from the dedication of health workers and doctors, to the beauty of nature as it lay undisturbed.  It is accompanied by paintings by Indian artist Vibha Pankaj who has lived in Scotland for 20 years. Fraser wonders how the empty Maidan in Kolkata would have looked on Poila Boishakh when there was no one to celebrate. Referring to the statue of Subhas Chandra Bose in Maidan, she says: “Is Netaji surprised to see the confluence of five roads bereft of traffic on the run/ while the Hooghly flows with renewed confidence?”

There is a poem about dolphins returning to the Hooghly as the smog lifted, but also of the green and beautiful valley of Srinagar that has been destroyed by firing. Fraser remembers the shikaras on the lake and the chinar trees and asks “How green was that valley?” She answers the question: “Till a thousand boots trampled through the valley/and gunshots drowned their songs. The lakes turned Red.” The site of migrant workers walking thousands of miles back to their villages reminded Fraser of the Partition and the movement of people. Yet, today they walked in a free country in their own land, but far from home. “Unwanted by those that they sustain, they start their long trek home,” she writes.

Fraser – author of the book From the Ganga to the Tay -- compares the two popular parks in her ancestral home in Kolkata and her present home in Edinburgh. In the deserted Maidan in Kolkata, no batsman was scoring a century, and no demonstrators were shouting slogans. In The Meadow in Edinburgh, no families were having picnics and playing with Frisbees. Both parks were silent.

The original article published in Anandabajar

Shrabani is a writer and journalist, author of ‘Victoria and Albert’, ‘Spy Princess’ and ‘The Mystery of the Parsee Lawyer’ and other books.

contributed by

Shrabani Basu

contributed by

Shrabani Basu

featured stories
books in this entry
more in this category
Read the English translation of Shrabani Basu’s review of ‘Patient Dignity’ which has been published in Anandabajar in their ‘London Diary’ column- a Bengali newspaper with the highest sales both in India and amongst the Bengali diaspora internationally.
featured stories